Jump to content
  • Welcome to Online Baptist

    Free to join.


  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Contributors to this sermon

Is Tithing a Sin?

Standing Firm In Christ


Is Tithing a Sin?

by Ronald W Robey

Is tithing money a sin? Yes, it is,... if you are tithing money because, "the Bible commands us to tithe.".

God's Word decides what is to be tithed, not us.  If the preacher's tithe sermon contradicts what is written in God's Holy Word, God is right, the preacher is wrong.  If man's belief concerning God's commanded tithe is contrary to what is written in the Bible about God's commanded tithe, God is right, man is wrong.  The decision as to what is to be tithed, to whom the tithe is to be given, and where it is to be observed has already been written in God's Word.  He said His holy tithe is agriculrural, not monetary. (Lev. 27:30-33)  He said it is for the physical descendants of Levi, not for Gentiles on Gentile soil. (Lev. 27:34; Num. 18:24-26; Neh. 10:37-38)

God's Word says that sin is the transgression of the Law. (1 John 3:4)  To say that God requires monetary tithes is false, since God's Word says His holy tithe is to be agricultural. To say that God's holy tithe is to be taken to Gentile pastors on Gentile soil is also false, since God said His holy tithes are to go to Levites in farming communities in Canaan.

When those who believe that God's Word commands them to tithe tithe money (instead of agricultural crops and livestock) and they tithe on Gentile soil, (instead of farming communities in Canaan) they transgress the very Law they claim to be keeping.

Yes, to tithe money in response to Leviticus 27:30, Malachi 3:10, Matthew 23:23, Luke 11:42 or Hebrews 7:5-9; or in response to any other Biblical command to tithe is,... in fact,... sin.



Recommended Comments

Back before about 1850, here in England, tithes were expected by the Church of England.  They had tithe barns to receive the gifts. There were maps to show what the tithes were based upon. Tithe maps were the most accurate ancient maps of some towns and villages.  I have referred more than once to the 1851 religious census where every religious organisation had to complete.  Some CofE ministers complained that people were no longer paying their tithes. They sometimes recorded their ministry as a "living" and worth a certain amount of pounds.  Some had more than one living and recorded the value of each.  They also had pew rents.  By that I assume that a family would rent a pew, often with a gate to it, and have a plaque with their name on it and woe betide any one who was not of the family who sat in it.  The census required the name of the minister, the number attending the previous weeks services, total number of seats and the number of free seats and various other information. The same was true of other denominations.  One near here said they had 300 seats* of which 150 were free,  (I have been in the building which is no longer a church but a club, and I cannot see how the could net 300 seats in there.  They had to extend the room outward to fit a full size snooker table in there .)  There is a plaque on the wall that says it was a baptist church then a Calvinistic Weslean Church but I researched it carefully and found no evidence of the latter.  It seemed to have been mostly funded by a local coal merchant, who died in 1852, and also a tea dealer.  In 1859 in a trade directory it is listed a Baptist and Ministers: Various. In 1867 when the current Baptist church was formed their minutes said that they could not use the former Baptist building as it was now a Plymouth Brethren. Later when that had their first baptism they used that building and thanked Mrs Wilson for its use.  Mrs Wilson's former husband was the coal merchant. It seems from snippets I found, there was a small Baptist church in the town from about 1860, called Noah's Ark,  The last I found of that was going through old baptist magazines in a library in London a letter from the pastor or elder? in 1866, welcoming everyone to the Ark on Sundays.  Not sure if that was incorporated into the present Baptist Church which was opened by Spurgeon and the first pastor was from Spurgeon's college. I don't think Spurgeon would have anything to do with them today.

Sorry I have digressed as usual.  The Anglican church was the only church that I found that required tithes.  The RCC may have as well but they charge for everything anyway.  

Share this comment

Link to comment

I haveordered a book by a minister named John Harvey Grime published 1934, copyright Library of Congress, Washington DC. (Should be here toward the end of the week)  


The book is very interesting from what I was able to read online, and relates the History of the Tennessee Baptist Church.  At the time of its printing, Grime stated that tithes were not a Baptist Doctrine, and that should the Baptist Church begin teaching tithing, it would cease being Baptist.

Edited by Standing Firm In Christ

Share this comment

Link to comment

The book arrived this morning.  Following is just a sample of what is  in the book:

               But as to the method of execution, we do not endorse the tithe system for the following reasons:

1.  It violates the divine plan laid down in the New Testament Scriptures.

2.  It violates every principle of Church polity upon which all our churches stand.

3.  If the Scriptures require our churches to tithe, we have not a single Scriptural church in our association. 

4.  It changes our giving from the realm of voluntary worship to that of slavish obedience to Law.

5.  It makes our churches tax gatherers.

6.  No Baptist Church has ever adopted it.  Should a church adopt it, they would cease to be Baptist.

7.  So far as History goes, it was never mentioned as a Christian or Church obligation until after the “great apostasy” in 250 A.D., and then only by the apostate church, and not by Baptists.  The agitation among Baptists, of this question, is of recent date.

8.  No Baptist Confession of Faith has ever mentioned it.

9.  It screens the rich, and oppresses the poor.

10.  Not one syllable in all the Bible that connects the tithe system with the churches of Jesus Christ.  When Baptists leave the Bible, they get into trouble.
-- John Harvey Grime; The Bible and History on the Tithe System, p.4; ©1934

Share this comment

Link to comment

The passage below in scripture has been abused by many Pastors and bible teachers alike who teach that this is a lesson about tithing; however, nothing in that context suggests that is the case. That passage is dealing with a woman who is trying to "earn" her way to heaven through works -- which is what the scribes and Pharisees taught. This widow gave all that she had (two mites -- 1/8 of a cent) believing that she would attain a right standing with God.

Then in the audience of all the people he said unto his disciples, Beware of the scribes, which desire to walk in long robes, and love greetings in the markets, and the highest seats in the synagogues, and the chief rooms at feasts; [Which devour widows' houses], and for a shew make long prayers: the same shall receive greater damnation. (Luke 20:45-47)

God Bless!

Edited by (Omega)

Share this comment

Link to comment

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Sermon Stats

    • Total Sermons
    • Total Entries
  • Sermons & Devotions

  • Blog Comments

    • It would have been much better if this was said at the beginning.
    • Repentance means a change of mind and heart toward God concerning sin.   When a person realizes that he is a sinner, repents of his sin, it is not a work.. repentance of sin is not a work.  A person who loves sin will not trust in Jesus.  Only those who realize their sinfulness and its condemnation, and need for deliverance would trust in Jesus as Savior.  Jesus said, I did not come to call the righteous but sinners to repentance (Mark 2: 17) .     There is no physical effort or physic
    • That's a very heavy rock to carry, thanks to the Grace of God, we do not have to carry it . When a person hear the gospel of salvation for the first time, can he or she accept Christ, for salvation without realizing they are a sinner. Do you want to accept Jesus Christ as your personal savior? Yes I do, just pray and say I believe in Jesus. That it, that easy? I believe a person must realize, that he or she is lost, and that we were born sinners.         (Repent means to realize)     
    • My question is you said that repentance of sin is a physical work, so do you believe that the sinner must repent of sin and believe to be saved, or you believe that it does not involve repentance of sin to be saved?   Do you believe that salvation is by works or by grace?      IS REPENTANCE OF SIN A WORK THAT YOU MUST STRIVE FOR? Thursday, May 14, 2020   According to some modern preachers, that repentance of sin is a work that you must strive for, that in order
    • Both, with the soul and physically. You have to be alive and breathing. Not by good works, (effort) but we seek to do good works, after we are saved. To please and be obedience, to  God. Not to be a busybody pleasing some pastor or man.
    • WHY REPENTANCE OF SIN IS NOT A WORK Salvation is not of works, Titus 3:5; 2 Timothy 1:9; Eph. 2:8-9, Romans 11:6. Salvation is by grace through faith, thus it cannot be mix with works, Eph.2:8, Rom.11:6. Grace and works cannot go together, Rom.11:6, Rom.4:4 Grace is harmonious with faith, but not with works, Eph.2:8-9, Titus 3:5 Repentance and faith are requisites to salvation, Mark 1:15; Acts 20:21; Heb.6:1 Repentance and faith are commands of the gosp
    • Why do you think that I do believe the same as them when I do not categorize "repent of sin" as a work whereas he repeatedly emphasize repentance of sin as a work.  Secondly, in my evangelism outline I include repentance which I do explain as repentance of sin.   Thirdly, I do not practice that repeat after me prayer phrase by phrase.   Now why do you think it is the same?   Of course there are basic in the gospel presentation that are the same for the believers of salvation by grace.  Can't you
    • A follow up on Question 3.  You stated that repent that "repent is an action word" Question No. 5 is: What kind of action do you mean, an act of the will in the soul of man, or a physical action that requires effort?  
    • Therefore there must be a change of mind first concerning sin, from loving sin to hating it, that is repentance toward God before he exercises faith toward our Lord Jesus.  
    • Choose this day whom ye shall serve. The person that does not want deliverance? Shall be left behind, for this man trusted not, and was almost persuaded to be a christian. Like king Agrippa, and others for they had much.  

Article Categories

About Us

Since 2001, Online Baptist has been an Independent Baptist website, and we exclusively use the King James Version of the Bible. We pride ourselves on a community that uplifts the Lord.

Contact Us

You can contact us using the following link. Contact Us or for questions regarding this website please contact @pastormatt or email James Foley at jfoley@sisqtel.net

Android App

Online Baptist has a custom App for all android users. You can download it from the Google Play store or click the following icon.

  • Create New...